Found search results for ""

Home > Blog

Read Time — 3 minutes

The Hidden Printer Problem: How One Device Can Destroy Your Profits (and How to Stop It)

High-toner printer costs impacting MPS profitability.

This blog was updated Sept. 5, 2025.

Summary: Not all printers on a contract perform the same. Some quietly eat into your profits with higher toner use or recurring service calls. The fix? Stop guessing and start tracking profitability at the per-device level with ERP-driven insights. That’s how you protect your margins before it’s too late.

 

Would you know if a single printer was siphoning profits from an equipment lease contract? Let’s take a look at three identical printers on contract that couldn’t be more different in their profitability.

A tale of three printers

Imagine you have a customer with 20 printers on contract, including these three seemingly identical devices. They’re all priced out similarly, assuming an average toner consumption rate.

  • Printer #1: Runs at expected usage levels, consuming toner and requiring service within the forecasted budget.
  • Printer #2: This printer was relocated to the finance department and has started to print greater volumes with greater page coverage, burning through toner at twice the expected rate.
  • Printer #3: This device had a few minor recurring issues, requiring visits from your technicians and replacement parts.

We can easily assume that Printer 2 and Printer 3 are less profitable than Printer 1. So problem solved, right?

Not really. There is no data here that tells you:

  • What is the exact impact on profits? Do you need to adjust pricing?
  • What about the rest of your fleet? Do you have the same insights to accurately assess the profitability of every device on every customer site?


You're not alone

According to the Managed Print Services Association (MPSA), nearly 60% of office equipment dealers struggle with surprise supply costs that eat into their profits. Disconnected systems make it nearly impossible to track profitability at the device level.

The cost of contract underperformance

This contract assumed an average number of toner shipments. But when the use of a single printer causes unexpectedly high toner shipments, costs for that device skyrocket!

If another device has a few repeated service issues, your labor expenses start adding up quick Over time, one or two underperforming devices can wipe out the profits from an entire contract.

One printer alone could run well over $15,000 in unplanned toner and service expenses over a year.

So which printer was the profit killer?

In this example, which printer was the one that killed the profits on that contract?

The answer?

None of them!

(Our apologies. it was a trick question!) This dealer received automatic contract profitability insights that provided early detection of cost issues, enabling contract terms and supply order optimization, before profits were impacted.

How to get early profitability insights

Fixing profitability leaks starts with integrating your ERP with device management and financial data, turning your ERP into a central hub for calculating per-device profitability, so you can:

  • Track device meters and supply usage automatically.
  • Identify high-cost devices before they erode margins.
  • Adjust pricing based on actual usage trends.
  • Optimize your supply chain to reduce overspending.

The right ERP centralizes all the data needed to optimize MPS revenue. Without this level of control, contract profitability is at risk.

Take control of your profits

Gain a clear view of your costs to protect your margins. Relying on spreadsheets or disconnected data is a gamble with your profitability. An industry-tailored ERP provides the visibility and control needed to guarantee every device under contract is profitable. Don’t allow a single printer to wipe out your margins—get the right tools to safeguard your business.

Why this matters

Think of it like a leaky faucet in your house. One drip doesn’t seem like much, but over time it can flood your kitchen. In contracts, a single “dripping” printer quietly drains thousands.

When your ERP gives you per-device visibility, you stop leaks before they become floods.

Summary

Profit killers hide in plain sight. The only way to find them is with integrated ERP insights. That’s how you keep every contract healthy and every device under control.

Profitability reporting is our secret sauce

Let us show you why e-automate dealers never worry about profit leaks.

FAQs

What is a “profit-killing printer”?

It’s a device on contract that uses way more toner than expected, needs constant service, or otherwise drives up costs so much that it erodes your overall profit margins.

How does ERP help with printer profitability?

An ERP integrates data from device meters, supply shipments, and financials. That lets you see profitability per device, not just per contract. With real-time alerts, you can act before costs spiral out of control.

Why does one bad printer matter so much?

Because contracts are priced on averages. If one printer doubles toner use or racks up service visits, those costs aren’t covered. That single device can eat away the profit for all 20 printers in a contract.

What’s the best way to stop hidden costs?

Automate insights. Don’t rely on spreadsheets or manual checks. With ERP-driven visibility, you can:

  • Track usage in real time
  • Identify problem devices early
  • Adjust pricing and supplies before losses add up

Isn’t this just about toner?

No. Toner is a big piece, but service calls, labor hours, and parts all play a role. ERP helps you track all the variables that affect profitability.